If you live in Utah, faith isn’t just what you do on a Sunday; it is often the water you swim in. It dictates your community, your family dynamics, your neighborhood interactions, and your core identity. So, when that faith begins to shift, it rarely feels like a simple change of mind. It feels like an existential earthquake.
At Liberated Mind Counseling, we use James Fowler’s Stages of Faith to help clients map out their spiritual development. Fowler provides a brilliant framework, showing how we move from the rule-following conformity of Stage 3 (“Synthetic-Conventional”) to the personal responsibility and nuance of Stage 4 (“Individuative-Reflective”), and perhaps eventually to the paradox-embracing Stage 5 (“Conjunctive”).
But there is a glaring omission in Fowler’s clean, academic model. He essentially dodged the sheer chaos of the transition itself.
The Missing Stage: The Void of Deconstruction
Fowler makes the jump between stages sound like a natural, albeit challenging, maturation process. But for those leaving a high-demand religion, the space between Stage 3 and Stage 4 isn’t just a stepping stone—it’s a distinct, grueling stage of its own. It is the “Dark Night of the Soul,” the deconstruction phase, or simply: The Void.
When the inherited symbols, literal beliefs, and community safety nets of Stage 3 collapse, you don’t instantly land in the reflective, self-authored peace of Stage 4. Instead, you enter a liminal space where the old rules no longer work, but the new rules haven’t been written yet.
Your brain’s problem-solving mind perceives this loss of identity and community not just as a philosophical dilemma, but as a literal threat to your survival. Your sympathetic nervous system kicks into overdrive. The result? Profound, paralyzing anxiety. You might experience a pounding heart, racing thoughts, a deep sense of grief, or a terrifying feeling of being unmoored.
How to Find Solid Footing
If you are trapped in this missing stage, held hostage by your own anxious thoughts, you are not alone—and you are not broken. This anxiety is a normal reaction to an overwhelming loss of certainty. Here is how we approach navigating this space at Liberated Mind:
- Return to the Pillars: Sleep, Diet, and Exercise (SDE)
Before we can tackle the existential dread, we have to look at your biology. Faith transitions are exhausting. If your nervous system is trapped in fight-or-flight, your brain cannot process complex emotional transitions. Prioritize your SDE. Get your sleep environment right, move your body to process the stress hormones, and nourish yourself. Absent attention to SDE, everything else will have limited efficacy. - Practice Psychological Flexibility (ACT)
As humans, our instinct is to run from what hurts. But in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), we learn that you hurt where you care. If you run from the vulnerability of this transition, you also run from what matters most to you. Instead of trying to “win the war” against your anxious mind, practice making healthy contact with those difficult thoughts and feelings. Allow the grief and fear to be there without letting them drive the car. - Discover Your Own Values
In Stage 3, your values were handed to you. In the void, you get to choose them. This is the ultimate self-liberation. What do you most deeply want to be about in your life? Authenticity? Compassion? Integrity? You can let these be informed by your past, but ultimately, it is between you and the person in the mirror. Once you connect with your “why,” the anxiety loses its sharpest teeth. - Withdraw the Mind (Mindfulness)
Our namesake, Liberated Mind, is a reference to the process of training the mind to withdraw from automatic, fear-based responses. When the anxiety screams that you are losing your family or your purpose, mindfulness allows you to step back. You learn to observe those stories without buying into them. (And yes, even you fidgety skeptics can do this!) - Find Your New Community
You do not have to navigate the void alone. Whether it’s through individual therapy, reaching out to friends who have walked this path, or joining a Faith Transition Group, connection is the antidote to the isolation of deconstruction.
Moving Forward
Faith transitions can be messy, and Fowler’s stages don’t always do justice to the sheer grit it takes to survive the space between them. But if you are willing to stop holding back and face the void with self-compassion, you will come out on the other side with renewed purpose, meaning, and a life that is genuinely yours.
If you are feeling stuck, anxious, or overwhelmed in your transition, you belong here. The team at Liberated Mind is ready to help you find your footing.
—
This post does not constitute therapeutic counseling or advice; the contents of this post are provided as a learning resource. We share the contents hoping that if you are in need of mental health support you will reach out to us directly or to a mental health professional in your area.
Share this message and then subscribe to this newsletter by signing up below.